Most recommended methods for visualising fingermarks on paper rely on chemical developers that target and react with amino acids. Traditionally, these developers are sprayed onto paper substrates in solutions of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), but now those same PFAS chemicals are undergoing phaseout or phasedown, which threatens to undermine forensic capabilities. This situation provides an opportunity to pivot towards greener approaches to fingermark visualisation. The ideal methodology would be a water-based treatment, as these provide superior safety for practitioners, combined with environmental sustainability. A major hurdle to implementing a water-based fingermark developer targeting amino acids is that water, as a universal solvent, can dissolve the eccrine components in fingermarks, as well as any optical or luminescent dyes that are created, causing the ridge detail to run or dissolve. This work circumvents this problem by delivering the amino acid developer alloxan in a hydrogel, which enables sharp fingermark ridge details to be observed despite it being a water-based treatment. Alloxan dissolved in a viscous hydrogel is shown here to react with the amino acids in fingerprint residues to form the coloured dye murexide, supported by optimisation and characterisation studies.