This paper discusses the challenges of implementing microgrids in fragmented communities and highlights the significance of community identity and active involvement of residents. Community identity fosters inclusiveness and support for social relationships. However, the impact of cooperative and conflictual relationships on governance arrangements and social and environmental outcomes has received limited attention in studies. To illustrate the importance of community involvement in the development of a microgrid, we consider a remote community in Australia with frequent power outages and poor internet connectivity. The study involved a survey and interviews to understand the community’s perspectives on the implementation of a microgrid, including their willingness to invest financially in purchasing and selling local renewable energy, their electricity usage patterns, their interest in hosting renewable energy sources, and their willingness to collaborate.