Blood is a non-Newtonian, shear-thinning fluid owing to the physical properties and behaviors of red blood cells (RBCs). Under increased shear flow, pre-existing clusters of cells disaggregate, orientate with flow, and deform. These essential processes enhance fluidity of blood, although accumulating evidence suggests that sublethal blood trauma—induced by supraphysiological shear exposure—paradoxically increases the deformability of RBCs when examined under low-shear conditions, despite obvious decrement of cellular deformation at moderate-to-higher shear stresses. Some propose that rather than actual enhancement of cell mechanics, these observations are “pseudoimprovements” and possibly reflect altered flow and/or cell orientation, leading to methodological artifacts, although direct evidence is lacking. This study thus sought to explore RBC mechanical responses in shear flow using purpose-built laser diffractometry in tandem with direct optical visualization to address this problem. Freshly collected RBCs were exposed to a mechanical stimulus known to drastically alter cell deformability (i.e., prior shear exposure (PSE) to 100 Pa × 300 s). Samples were subsequently transferred to a custom-built slit-flow chamber that combined laser diffractometry with direct cell visualization. Cell suspensions were sheared in a stepwise manner (between 0.3 and 5.0 Pa), with each step being maintained for 15 s. Deformability and cell orientation indices were recorded for small-scatter Fraunhofer diffraction patterns and also visualized RBCs. PSE RBCs had significantly decreased visualized and laser-derived deformability at any given shear stress ≥1 Pa. Novel, to our knowledge, observations demonstrated that PSE RBCs had increased heterogeneity of direct visualized orientation with flow vector at any shear, which may be due to greater vorticity and thus instability in 5-Pa flow compared with unsheared control. These findings indicate that shear exposure and stress-strain history can alter subsequent RBC behavior in physiologically relevant low-shear flows. These findings may yield insight into microvascular disorders in recipients of mechanical circulatory support and individuals with hematological diseases that alter physical properties of blood.