We studied sorption potential for a range of herbicides using eleven waste materials (mill muds) containing organic matter (47.6 to 65.1%) produced by sugar mills and applied as soil conditioners by farmers. Sorption/desorption behaviour of five herbicides commonly used in sugarcane production (imazapic, atrazine, hexazinone, diuron and metribuzin) was studied on these mill muds, as is and after adding these to three soils at different rates (5–25%, dry weight basis). All mill muds had significant sorption capacity, especially for diuron, atrazine and metribuzin which was 6 to 26 times higher than the soil with 3.5% organic carbon (OC). Generally, sorption of the five herbicides assessed in all mill muds followed the order diuron > atrazine = metribuzin > hexazinone = imazapic. Eight out of 11 mill muds had similar sorption capacity for any given herbicides. Amending soils with selected mill muds significantly enhanced their sorption efficiency, depending on the rate of application especially in soil with low OC. Generally, application of mill muds at 5% w/w or 40 tons/ha increased sorption of studied herbicides by 2 to 10 folds. Soil amendment with mill muds also reduced the rate and extent of desorption of herbicides- especially mobile herbicides like metribuzin. Nearly 79% release of metribuzin was observed after three desorption steps in amended soil (at 5% w/w), whereas in unamended soil, 100% of metribuzin was released during first desorption step. The study demonstrates that wastes produced by sugar mills may have recycling use in enhancing the retention of mobile herbicides in soils with low OC content.